How your entry is assessed
The questions we ask, the evidence we look for, and how independent scores become a result.
A growing business should not be assessed the same way as a community organisation. An innovation award should not ask the same questions as a leadership award. The criteria change by category — the principles behind them do not.
The criteria for every category are published before entries open, so you always know what you are being assessed against.
01Assessed against your category
Each category is judged against criteria written for it. A few illustrative examples of what a category can weigh:
- Growth — commercial performance, scalability and progress.
- Innovation — originality, implementation and impact.
- Leadership — people, direction, culture and outcomes.
- Community impact — contribution, reach and measurable difference.
02What judges look for
- Relevance — how well your entry answers the criteria for the category.
- Evidence — the strength and credibility of what you can show, not just what you claim.
- Achievement in context — the scale of what you achieved relative to your size and situation.
- Clarity of outcomes — concrete, verifiable results rather than intentions.
- Authenticity — a truthful account you can stand behind.
03Assessed by more than one judge
Your future should not rest on one person’s opinion. Each entry is assessed independently by more than one judge, and their scores are averaged. Judges may not always agree — and they do not need to. The objective is multiple perspectives, consistent criteria and fair assessment.
Example — three judges score 82, 76 and 88. The averaged professional score is 82.
04Scored, then locked
Judges complete their assessments. Where public voting applies, it closes and is validated. Then every score is locked — and only then does the system combine them by the predefined weightings. No one can revise a score after seeing how others assessed, and no person does the final maths.
05What each stage means
- Semi-Finalist — your entry reached the required level within the process.
- Finalist — your achievements stood out among the strongest entries in the category.
- Runner-Up — you were assessed among the very best in the category.
- Winner — your entry emerged at the top of the Standard.
You don’t buy your way through this journey. You earn your way through it.
Different awards. Different measures of excellence. One consistent Standard.
The documents behind every result
Methodology
You are hereJudging Criteria
What judges look for, how entries are scored, and how a result is reached.